Casey’s Pizza House Reviews, Ratings & Menu

General Info

Nestled right on 801 E Main St in Floyd, VA, Casey's Pizza House is the kind of place that makes you feel instantly at home the moment you walk through the door. The cozy, casual vibe is perfect for a relaxed lunch or a quick bite between errands, and the friendly staff adds a personal touch that keeps locals and visitors coming back. Whether you're stopping by for a solo meal or grabbing a pie with friends, Casey's menu caters to everyone looking for that satisfying pizza experience.

One of the highlights of the menu has to be their signature pizzas, crafted with a perfect balance of gooey cheese, flavorful toppings, and a crust that's just the right mix of crisp and chewy. Every slice tastes fresh, and you can really tell that quality ingredients are a priority here. For those who prefer a lighter option, they offer a variety of lunch selections beyond pizza, making it a versatile spot for anyone visiting Floyd.

The restaurant’s services make dining easy and convenient. Curbside pickup is available, so you can enjoy your favorite slices without even stepping inside if you're on the go. Inside, the space is clean and welcoming, complete with restroom facilities that are well-maintained. Payment is smooth and modern too-Casey’s accepts debit cards and even NFC mobile payments, making transactions fast and hassle-free.

Reviews from locals consistently praise Casey’s for its consistent quality and friendly atmosphere. People often mention the warm, inviting environment and the sense of community that comes from a place where everyone feels like a regular. Beyond the great food, the location is easily accessible, making it an ideal stop whether you’re exploring Floyd or just passing through.

For anyone looking for a pizza restaurant that combines delicious, freshly made dishes with convenience and a personal touch, Casey’s Pizza House stands out. The menu options are thoughtfully prepared, the service is attentive, and the overall experience leaves a lasting impression that keeps guests coming back time and again. Whether you’re picking up a quick lunch or enjoying a casual meal in a welcoming spot, Casey’s offers a genuine, satisfying experience for every pizza lover in the area.

What customers say?

“ You can’t go wrong eating here or taking out. Best pizza around and so much more to choose from. Located right behind Subway. You can dine-in or choose to eat outside on the picnic tables. There is a drive through for call in and online orders. ”

- S. J. -

“ We picked up a pizza and it was done right on time. The Italian crust is perfect, not too thin and not too thick. PLENTY of toppings, too! We wished we had gotten a smaller one because with all the toppings it was so filling. Bread sticks were good, and the cheese on top was broiled to a perfect golden brown. Friendly staff! Will definitely go back! ”

- Kay Davenport -

“ Awesome food. Great service. Tastes so fresh. Nothing comparable. Had the individual everything thick crust pizza and BLT pizza. Sub, bread sticks and marinara sauce. Will be back ”

- Gloria Scucchi -

“ We have owned a cabin in Floyd for 15 years. When drive in for a long weekend visit we typically eat what ever we have in the freezer. Tonight we ordered from Casey’s…..we are native Chicago folks and Italian…..we were so thrilled with our first experience with Casey’s. Ordering on our phone was easy, great prices, easy drive through window (we were 10 minutes early and she pulled it out of a warming oven) and the best was the taste. Wow….we were so pleased and yes, surprised. We now have a new drive into Floyd ritual. Pizza from Casey’s! ”

- Denise Williamson -

“ Went here on my honeymoon and it was great!! Pretty good service, my husband got pizza and I got wings. A little pricey but very good. He rated the pizza 8/10, and my wings were AMAZING. Some of the best wings I've ever had. The cheese sticks were a little under done but still pretty good. ”

- Hope Greene -

“ We haven't eaten here since they first opened, as the food at that time was horrible and tasted like chemicals. We were unknowingly served pizza from here this weekend and it was absolutely fantastic. When we asked where the pizza was from and were told Casey's, we couldn't believe it! What a complete turn around! We even stopped in the next night and got a couple of pizzas to go. Flavor of the fresh pizza and leftover was consistent to what we were served. We WILL be back. To the owner: Great job at the turn around and improvments. You have gained another customer! ”

- Michelle Southern -

“ We decided to dine at Casey’s because nothing else in Floyd was open on Christmas Eve. We were hungry and didn’t bring high expectations to the meal, but the thin crust alfredo pizza was a lovely surprise. The crust had a delightful snap without being cracker thin, and the layer of alfredo beneath the golden blanket of mozzarella was on par with sauces we’ve tasted from such establishments as Forlini’s in NYC. While folks may neglect Casey’s for places with more notoriety in downtown Floyd, you heard it here first: Don’t sleep on Casey’s or Casey’s will sleep on you. And you’d be a fool not to jump on their cheesy coattails. ”

- Amanda Mitchell -

“ Best Alternative to a new York style Pizza shop. I don't usually like anything other the brick oven pizza but this place is pretty goo ”

- Jojo Masa -

Welcome to Casey's Pizza House

General Info

Casey's Pizza House menu

Casey's Pizza House Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places